The metropolis
Historically, cities (by virtue of being a center of power) achieved status through their architectural display of wealth, accumulated sometimes through trade, more often through thievery accompanied by the occasional genocide, which historians commonly call ‘colonialisation’. In Berlin, the grandeur never lasted long, since it only became the capital of a nation with the German unification of 1871, whereas London and Paris were capitals of great colonial empires.
Hitler (there he is) had some extravagant plans for the city to become ‘Welthauptstadt’ Germania, capital of an empire which was to last a thousand years – a city only to be compared to Ancient Rome and Babylon – but things turned out a little awkward.
I’m reading a bundle of collected stories about Berlin, amongst others by Nabokov, Nooteboom, Alfred Döblin and Joseph Roth. It also contains a chapter from a book by Dutch journalist Philippe Remarque, of which the main theme is Berlin’s status as a metropolis. Supposedly, Berliners were always envious of Paris and London. Berlin still had something to prove, even though Germany had won the war of 1870. At the eve of the First World War Berlin was the third largest city in Europe, and it’s status as a metropolis was epitomized by Potsdamer Platz. Even when Germany lost the war, Potsdamer Platz thrived and during the Interbellum it was the center of nightlife, traffic and culture; then, after the Second World War, it was a wasteland between East and West for almost half a century.
Since a decade and a half or so Potsdamer Platz is an urban area again, and most notably is home to the terrible Sony center. The view from the square itself is alright, it’s even pleasant how there remains a sense of space, since the skyscrapers only surround the square on one side, while the other side is open and in effect merges with the adjacent Leipziger Platz. According to the essay, the redevelopment of Potsdamer Platz was the city’s main project, a symbol of its revival. The writer quotes some city executive as saying that ”in ten or twenty years Berlin will be a metropolis again.”
Now- what-are-you-talking-about? Is it not a metropolis? If is isn´t, does it fucking matter?
The bourgeois mentality of caring about status is understandable in 1913, as the spirit of the era, but not anymore today, certainly not after the War. For what is Berlin today? It is, for sure, the most talked about city in Europe, with its vibrant and diverse cultural life. Amongst its citizens it counts many open-minded, free-spirited and creative people, while the living is affordable and the city provides in abundance what is most important: possibilities to live a good and meaningful life.
It is, in short, the exact opposite of what Hitler envisioned.
(After all, Hitler was a petty bourgeois, who not only cared about imagery, he believed in it, he believed in it so much that he, well, instead of transforming Berlin into a new Babylon, destroyed half of Europe.)
Had the writer of the essay talked to the people, common people, different people, the city with all it shades and colours would have appeared, and what’s more will appear as a wondrous place, given what it has become today, in the light of its history.. Instead, these thoughts on what makes a city a metropolis seem a little divorced from reality. Hardly anyone in Berlin would care for the comparison. And then, to think that as a metropolis it is inferior to London or Paris – who wants to be London or Paris, especially if you are Berlin.
Besides, it is senseless to compare cities. I never do it.
However, now that we’re at it: coming from Paris it is hard not to think about the tremendous contrast between the two cities. Both are capitals of great European nations, but worlds apart. Paris is rich, Berlin relatively poor; Paris is dense, Berlin vast; Paris is coherent, intact – Berlin a broken mosaic; Paris is beautiful, Berlin, well, as the old Prussian motto has it: to each his own. But Berlin is is neither ugly nor pretty. It is, above all, real.
Paris is suffocating, especially in summer; Berlin is a city that breathes. People in Paris are tense, in Berlin they are relaxed. In Paris pride is worn in self-indulgence of different proportions. In Berlin, it is worn as kindness and enthusiasm. Paris, despite everything, is French; Berlin, because of everything, is not German. In France there are no officially recognized minorities, while in Berlin there is so much of everything that there is no dominant culture. Finally, Paris is eternal, Berlin the city of change.
I love both cities in a different way. It´s good to love in different ways.
For the record: I don´t really give much of a fuck for Potsdamer Platz, I have no business there. But I mention it for two reasons. Firstly, because it is the symbol of the current of change which I talked about earlier, and I’m happy to know that many Berliners treat it with a mixture of disregard and contempt; secondly, because as long as I can remember I have had a fascination for urban space.
The direct experience of walking through the city is street level. At that, the entourage of the square is rather tasteless; when you walk through the Alte Potzdamer Strasse to Marlene Dietrich-Platz, you think Berlin pulls a bad joke on you. You would expect to find it in the Dutch city Almere, with the street ending in a particularly nasty little pond with a spiritually impotent fountain, next to which is a theatre-cinema or whatever it is with which they insult Marlene Dietrich´s memory. On the whole, while some of the architecture of the quarter is fine, some of it is too ugly for radio. The Sony center in particular, which is already a bit narcissistic and overrated, is a disgrace. The central problem is the corporate mindset with which the area has been reconstructed.
Essentially what we touch on here is the question of public space. Space, and therefore architecture, communicates something. When a city’s grandeur is equated with the presence of capital, something, some very essential human quality is lost or denounced. The artificial, corrupted flow of capital in our days is what drives societies apart. Its symbols therefore are not merely symbols, they are propaganda.
In a way, buildings like the Sony center convey two things: a certain arrogance (who dominates the space) and a lie – as if it is a present given to the people of the city.
For me, the charm of city life consists in the city being a scene, an embrace – not a decor with the pretense of being a painting.
But let’s forget about Potsdamer Platz, let the Japanese and the Americans have a wank because Sony and Daimler built that shit, and get back to city life, to the immediacy of reality.
*
Summer life in Berlin: riding waves and being in between
I spend two weeks in Berlin in a crazy rhythm, being awake till dawn, sleeping till the afternoon. I stroll through the city endlessly, getting nowhere, then usually meeting up with people in a bar during the evening. The first week that I stay with Peter I’m more or less forced to do so anyway, since he has a lot of things to do during the day and he doesn’t have a pair of spare keys. One night I’m exhausted after we attend a concert of the Mystical Communication Service, the band of his friend Yanez, who also owns the bar where we stay for drinks. But Peter has many friends and at 5 in the morning still wants to go around, change places, which has me strolling along in his wake while he belts a song he’s working on: “Ice Cream baby, I scream baby, we are in Babylon! Runaway Roots..”
Long after the sun has risen his energy finally runs low and his spirits direct him back to the bunker, to swim in the dim light of a room filled with music..
(Little portrait of Peter)
In general Peter is really on a roll these days. He’s living hard, intense, with a great sense of self but without ego – living with his heart, his surrender rooted in a keen understanding of the different waves of life, the processes of growth.
I am in a way in awe of it, and for a while my mind is making images of an enormous contrast between our two characters. I am not making a caricature of him, he is really on the roll – but I am making a caricature out of myself. I, too, know the highs, and the lows, and Peter for sure knows his.. what it is to hit one´s head against the wall.
During the day Peter is mostly going around town doing stuff. A couple of nights in a row we meet in a bar with Sam and Jasper, two Flemish friends of Peter who are passing by Berlin on a road trip. The best moments are when our conversation takes a turn and Peter gets up and enters in a spiral of storytelling, his whole body moving with the words. He speaks fast and fluent, with his greasy Antwerpian accent; the stories are always juicy, and when he tells about the play it’s with such sheer joy and charisma that it’s contagious. He has the cheekiness of a scruff, but it is somehow warm all the way through. His style is half-rugged, half casual. He is passionate, at times electrifying, a big chunk of feeling that loves and knows how to live on or close to the edge, but is too fond of life to self-destruct. For the sake of experience he keeps no distance, however, he dives in himself before he gets sucked in, always making sure he comes up again.
Some fragments, moments, memories
Experience is fragmentary and I couldn’t write a narrative of these days in Berlin.
[to be continued]